Live Musical in Lancaster, PA: Stolen

May 1 – October 23, 2019

A small Pennsylvania town is shaken when Zack Fisher, the infant son of a prominent Amish family, is kidnapped. Accusations fly. Although everyone comes under suspicion, the case goes cold. Zack’s sister Naomi, who was supposed to be watching him, blames herself for the next 20 years – then takes matters into her own hands. Packed with a cast of interesting and complex characters, including a quirky, noir-style detective and an amateur Amish sleuth, this musical mystery tells a moving story about learning to forgive yourself.

Presented in partnership with Blue Gate Musicals, with a script by Martha Bolton based on Wanda Brunstetter’s best-selling Daughters of Lancaster County series, this light-hearted whodunit is brought to life by a talented cast of professionals. Chosen from 5,000 hopefuls at auditions across the country, our cast members have appeared at Sight & Sound Theatres, Ozark Actors Theatre, Peach State Summer Theatre, Lexington Children’s Theatre, South Bend Civic Theatre and other venues. This production includes several veterans of the Bird-in-Hand Stage.

If faith, family and self-forgiveness matter to you, Stolen will steal your heart.

For tickets, call (717) 768-1568, visit our box office or reserve online.

Buy Tickets Online

Show Times

Check Availability

Show Times & Ticket Prices

May 1 – October 23, 2019

Dinner & Show
Monday – Thursday: Adult, $56; Child, $30
Friday – Saturday: Adult, $58; Child, $30

Lunch & Show
Monday – Saturday: Adult, $53; Child, $27

Breakfast & Show
Monday – Saturday: Adult, $48; Child, $24

Show Only
Monday – Saturday: Adult, $38; Child, $17

Guests dining with us before the performance should arrive at least 90 minutes prior to allow for time to enjoy their meal. If you arrive later than that time, we are not able to guarantee you will be finished dining in time to be seated for the live musical. Stage doors open 30 minutes prior to show time.


Bird-in-Hand Stage in Lancaster County, PA:
2760 Old Philadelphia Pike, #A
Bird-in-Hand, PA 17505
(Get Google Maps Directions »)

“I loved it and so did my husband who said beforehand he does not like musicals.”

— lscolvin, Union City, MI

Wholesome Entertainment Everyone Will Enjoy

Our Bird-in-Hand Stage makes it easy to relax and enjoy high-quality live entertainment, including Broadway-style musical theatre and magic shows with a positive message, in a unique Lancaster County setting.

  • Intimate 175-seat theatre
  • Tiered seating with wheelchair-accessible floor seating
  • Delicious on-site dining
  • Convenient on-site lodging options
  • Tickets available as part of a discounted meal and/or lodging package
  • Theatre season runs March-January with various show times

Escape your everyday world for a little while and enjoy our live stage shows. You’ll find yourself laughing, holding your breath, gasping, tapping your toes – uplifted and fully entertained.

See what has to say about Stolen!

Call (717) 768-1568 to purchase tickets or reserve them online:

Meet Our Talented Cast

Live Musical in Lancaster, PA Cast: Anna Beth Riggs

Anna Beth Riggs

Anna Beth holds a BFA in musical theatre from Samford University. Originally from western Kentucky, Anna Beth is excited to be in Pennsylvania with Blue Gate Musicals this season. She has performed in The Little Mermaid, The Addams Family, Charlotte’s Web, Children of Eden, and The Last Five Years. She is also a proud Equity Membership Candidate.

Live Musical in Lancaster, PA Cast: Monica Depaul

Monica Depaul

This is Monica’s fifth season with Blue Gate Musicals. She has previously appeared in Josiah for President, The Confession, Half-Stitched, Home Game, A Christmas to Remember and more! A California native with a degree in musical theater, she performed at Sight & Sound Theatres for 10 years. She has also worked with Fulton Theatre, PRiMA Theatre, Servant Stage Company, Portrait of a Lady Summer Cabaret Series and Cavod Theatre.

Live Musical in Lancaster, PA Cast: Catherine Patton

Catherine Patton

Originally from Opelika, AL, Catherine graduated from Samford University with a BFA in Musical Theater in May of 2018. She has spent this past year working with various children’s theater companies, living and performing in ten different states! She would like to thank her family for their unending support of her current nomad lifestyle as well as the entire Blue Gate family for this incredible opportunity.

Live Musical in Lancaster, PA Cast: Nathan Garner

Nathan Garner

Nathan is thrilled to be returning for his fifth season acting at Bird-in-Hand Stage and his third as the Technical Manager. Nathan has enjoyed playing roles such as Josiah in Josiah for President, Hovie in Mennonite Girls Can Cook and David in The Home Game. Outside of the theater he enjoys rock climbing, archery, and bonfires. He wants to thank his castmates and everyone behind the scenes who helps make the show happen everyday. Enjoy the show!

Live Musical in Lancaster, PA Cast: Matthew Hayes Hunter

Matthew Hayes Hunter

Originally from Cookeville, Matthew attended Middle Tennessee State University. He has performed in Disney’s Newsies, Rock of Ages, Seussical the Musical, Little Shop of Horrors, You’re A Good Man, Charlie Brown and RENT. Recently, he served as First Assistant Director and Casting Director for two faith-based feature films and has also worked with Disney, ABC, CMT, Investigation Discovery and many others.

Live Musical in Lancaster, PA Cast: Richard Weaver

Richard Weaver

Richard is so thrilled to be a part of this production! Last October he was in the original cast of Treasure Island at the Fulton Theatre. He has also performed in Disney’s Newsies and The Hunchback of Notre Dame at Fulton Theatre and in Cavod Theatre’s production of Seussical the Musical. A big thanks to God, friends and his family.

Live Musical in Lancaster, PA Cast: Miles Barnum

Miles Barnum

Originally from Fargo, ND Miles has an MFA in Acting from Western Illinois. This past year, Miles directed a production of Dreamgirls in Philadelphia and has also performed in Joseph with Sight & Sound Theatre, Lancaster. Credits include roles in A Streetcar Named Desire, Miss Saigon, Much Ado About Nothing and Rent. In a recent stint on the West Coast in LA, Miles was on The Good Place, Code Black and Brooklyn 99 among others.

Live Musical in Lancaster, PA Cast: Jay Mullens

Jay Mullens

Jay is a graduate from MTSU’s Theatre and Dance department. He is excited to join the Blue Gate ensemble and to tell this wonderful story here in Pennsylvania. Past acting credits: Newsies (PSST!), A Christmas Carol (Sacramento Theatre Company), and Brighton Beach Memoirs (MTSU). He wants to thank his supportive family and friends, as well as all of you, the wonderful people in the audience who keep theatre alive. Enjoy the show!

Live Musical in Lancaster, PA Cast: Deanna Oglesby

Deanna Oglesby

Deanna is from a thriving small town called Greenville, KY. She graduated with her BFA degree with a concentration in Musical Theater in May 2018. Deanna is very excited to be making her debut with Blue Gate Musicals, and she wants to thank her family and friends for always letting her sing in the car. Ephesians 2:4-10.

Live Musical in Lancaster, PA Cast: Nathan Kiliany

Nathan Kiliany

Nathan is excited to be performing in his first show on the Bird-in-Hand Stage. He is a graduate of Ohio Northern University’s BFA musical theater program. He has appeared in various professional productions in Ohio, Pennsylvania, and North Carolina, performing in Dracula, Sweeney Todd, Pirates of Penzance, and All Shook Up.

Amish Country Home Cooking

Our Bird-in-Hand Stage adds new flexibility to the concept of a dinner theatre in Lancaster, PA. To enhance your Lancaster County theatre experience, come early or stay after the show to enjoy a meal at our Bird-in-Hand Family Restaurant & Smorgasbord, where you can order from the menu or select from our mouthwatering all-you-can-eat buffet. If you’re looking for lighter fare, enjoy the farm-fresh choices at our nearby Bird-in-Hand Bakery & Cafe. Be sure to ask about dining discounts when you make your reservations.

Restaurant & Smorgasbord

Stay Overnight: Experience Smucker Family Hospitality

Our on-site dining options are a delicious way to round out your visit to our Bird-in-Hand Stage. For an even more memorable theatre experience, ask about discounted packages that include meals or lodging at our one of our conveniently located properties, which provide easy access to all the most popular Lancaster County attractions.

2760 Old Philadelphia Pike,
Bird in Hand, PA, USA

The Bird-in-Hand Stage is located on the banquet level of the Bird-in-Hand Family Restaurant & Smorgasbord. Wheelchair-accessible floor seating is available.

Contact For More Info:
Phone: (717) 768-1568


Call (717) 768-1568 to purchase tickets or reserve them online: