For more than a century, peanut butter cookies have been popular in Pennsylvania Dutch Country and beyond. If you like Lancaster County baked goods, you’re sure to love our crispy take on these classic treats. They’re scratch made in our bakery from sugar, light brown sugar and plenty of creamy peanut butter, so you get more of that that fresh-roasted peanut flavor in every bite.
* This is a perishable item and must be shipped 2nd Day Air to any location other than on the east coast.
Two dozen crispy peanut butter cookies made from scratch in our Amish Country bakery. They freeze well, so order some for now and some for later! Nationwide delivery.
We suggest freezing our shoofly pies, whoopie pies and cookies if you are not going to consume them within 1–2 days after you receive your order. For best results, wrap them in tin foil and thaw at room temperature.
Our bakery items may contain or come into contact with wheat/gluten, eggs, peanuts, tree nuts, milk or soy products. Please email or call (800) 524-3429 for further details.
12 × 9 × 5 in
shrink wrapped on a styrofoam tray and packed in a brown box