View Cart

Jumbo Whoopie Pie Sampler (12-count)

SKU: N/A Category:
(7 customer reviews)


We offer our large Whoopie Pies in several popular flavors, including original chocolate, peanut butter, pumpkin and red velvet. Every one of these Lancaster County baked goods is so delicious that it can be hard to choose. Our 6-count Jumbo Whoopie Pie Sampler lets you order two different flavors. With our 12-count Jumbo Whoopie Pie Sampler, you can order up to four different flavors – so try them all.

*This item is perishable. We ship orders out Monday-Wednesday each week. Holidays and/or inclement weather may cause delays. See shipping details.

How to order — Our whoopie pies are packaged in packs of 3 pies. Customize your order below by mixing and matching your flavor choices. You may choose 4 packs of the same flavor or mix and match any flavor combination.

Choose Your Flavors (3 whoopie pies per option):

7 reviews for Jumbo Whoopie Pie Sampler (12-count)

  1. George Mynarcik

    These are very good

  2. S (verified owner)

    We served these to friends from Belgium. They liked them better than the Tastycakes. Would by from this vender again.

  3. Brittany (verified owner)

    The same great quality you receive in store! Will definitely order again!

  4. Deborah Downes (verified owner)

    I had tasted these whoopie pies when we’d recently visited an Amish Village in PA. They were so delicious & I knew I wanted to order them for Thanksgiving. My expectations were exceeded not only by the quality, but also by the timely shipping & the care taken to wrap the pies so they weren’t crushed.

  5. Jeff Frost (verified owner)

    Best whoopie pies on earth. No others can come close.

  6. Dawn (verified owner)

    Amazing experience ordering online from start to finish. Alicia was so responsive to answering my questions about delivery and freezing the whoopie pies. They arrived right on time, and I froze them for the three days from delivery to my event. They thawed at room temperature beautifully! They were so delicious and fresh. My guests went crazy for them! I will surely be ordering again.

  7. Susan (verified owner)

    Ordered as a gift . Easy of ordering and fast delivery. The recipient of these delicious whoopie pie’s. Commented on how fresh they were and is thoroughly enjoying these sweet treats. Thank you for letting us have a little taste of amish country delivered to our door steps

Add a review

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.


Jumbo Whoopie Pie Sampler

Jumbo Whoopie Pies in a variety of flavors. Choose from:

  • Original: Chocolate cake with vanilla filling
  • Peanut Butter: Chocolate cake with peanut butter filling
  • Pumpkin: Pumpkin cake with vanilla filling
  • Red Velvet: Red velvet cake with buttercream filling

Choose up to four flavors (3 of each) to create your sampler. Nationwide delivery.

12-count whoopie pies are also available in a gift box. 

We suggest freezing our shoofly pies, whoopie pies and cookies if you are not going to consume them within 1–2 days after you receive your order. For best results, wrap them in tin foil and thaw at room temperature.

Our bakery items may contain or come into contact with wheat/gluten, eggs, peanuts, tree nuts, milk or soy products.  Please email or call (800) 524-3429 for further details.

Weight N/A
Dimensions 9.5 × 9.5 × 3.7 in
Whoopie Pie Cake flavor:

Chocolate, Pumpkin, Red Velvet

Whoopie Pie Filling Flavor:

Peanut Butter, Vanilla

Item Shape: