View Cart

Grandma Smucker’s Shoofly Pie

Categories: ,
(16 customer reviews)


Few foods are as closely associated with Lancaster County as shoofly pie. We’re famous for Grandma Smucker’s Shoofly Pie – a favorite of visitors to Bird-in-Hand. This traditional Pennsylvania Dutch wet-bottom shoofly pie is made from an old family recipe that has been handed down for generations and fine-tuned by Grandma Smucker.

What’s in shoofly pie? Fresh from our Lancaster County bakery, it is a mouthwatering combination of a light syrup, eggs, flour, brown sugar and cinnamon topped with crumbs in our flakey pie crust. Enjoy for breakfast, serve it for dessert or give it as a unique gift.

*This item is perishable. We ship orders out Monday-Wednesday each week. Holidays and/or inclement weather may cause delays. See shipping details.

16 reviews for Grandma Smucker’s Shoofly Pie

  1. Carlyle Ulberg

    5 star

  2. Susan Payne

    This pie is absolutely DELICIOUS!! Packaged well, shipped on time….EXCELLENT experience. Thank you!

  3. Donna Coble

    The pies are delicious — moist and not too sweet.
    They arrived fairly quickly and were carefully packaged. I was very pleased!

  4. Dennis A Bytheway (verified owner)

    I love shoofly pie since I was about five years old. We were from the Philly area, moved to Lansdale through high school. Lived in Manheim after I got out of the service. So I’ve eaten and the bird in hand restaurant, I would imagine you’re affiliated. Great family dining and your online store is great. I’m getting old are used to make my own funny cakes, and shoofly pies. Too old now to be messing with it. Since I brought up funny cake, do you have that in stock from time to time. And there’s an apple butter, tar black in color, Buckmans, something like that.
    Enjoy your products you guys are great. Folks that have an eaten from the Dutch country. Don’t know what they’re missing. Bird in hand was our favorite family dining.
    Thanks so much for your service, I miss that part of the country. Now in Florida.

  5. Jodi Felegie (verified owner)

    Thank you so much the pie made it to Arizona perfectly. My aunt and uncle enjoyed it very much. Thanks Jodi felegie

  6. Juanita Ancharski (verified owner)

    I sent the Shoofly pie as a birthday gift, the recipient loved it and it arrived on time and in perfect condition.

  7. Tracey (verified owner)

    As this pie was purchased for a friend who grew up in that area, I am sure that the pie was perfect as I haven’t heard anything. Thank you for making her day special.

  8. James Reyner (verified owner)

    Four pies were shipped as advertised and arrived in excellent condition in Saratoga CA. So far, our friends have consumed two, with no complaints!

  9. Tom

    The absolute best

  10. Robin Wallace (verified owner)

    I have ordered pies from Bird in Hand many times over the last several years. Never ever disappointed! Everything always perfect and packed perfect!! Love all their items.

  11. Brenda DeJoice (verified owner)

    Five stars here!!!!!!! I’ve been craving Shoofly pie since moving to the South. I was going to save it for the holiday, but I am eating away at half, and gave the other half away. It was a hit.
    I believe I’m going to have to order another, along with the cookie assortment. I miss those PA Dutch delicacies!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  12. Anonymous

    So very good! I learned about Shoofly pie in my Folklore class and just had to try it! It got to me fast, within a week of ordering it.

  13. Michele (verified owner)

    I lived in Pennsylvania while growing up and one of the staples we had was SHOO-FLY PIE!
    We moved far away when I was young. I now live in the South. I introduced my family here to Shoo-fly pie. IT WAS A HIT! DELICIOUS! Now others want to try it. Ever thought about expanding?

  14. Debbie Binger (verified owner)

    I was so hungry for shoofly pie. Being stuck in Florida for the time being I didn’t know where to find one. I went online and came across Bird-in-Hand. I received my pie and even though it’s not Grandma’s it was excellent!!!!!!!!!!! Now if you only carried dried beef and fresh sausage Thank you!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  15. D in TN (verified owner)

    Growing up in Pennsylvania my grandfather was Pennsylvania Dutch.
    My grandmother and mother always made this pie.
    I haven’t had it for many years. Just like I remember.

  16. Margie (verified owner)

    Had it delivered as a birthday gift. They loved it! Packaged well and arrived on time.

Add a review

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.


Grandma Smucker’s Shoofly Pie

Traditional 10-inch Amish-style wet-bottom shoofly pie made from a light syrup, eggs, flour, brown sugar and cinnamon in a flavorful scratch-made crust. Mail order shoofly pie, a Double Delight Pie Lover’s Gift Box with your choice of shoofly or pecan pie, or choose a Shoofly Pie Bonus Gift Bundle with 3 pies and 6 free Jumbo Original Whoopie Pies.

We suggest freezing our shoofly pies if you are not going to consume them within 1–2 days after you receive your order. For best results, wrap them in tin foil and thaw at room temperature.

Our bakery items may contain or come into contact with wheat/gluten, eggs, peanuts, tree nuts, milk or soy products. Please email or call (800) 524-3429 for further details.

Weight 5 lbs
Dimensions 10 × 10 × 3 in

1 10-inch Shoofly Pie, 1 Grandma Smucker’s Shoofly Pie in a decorative gift box, Your choice of: 2 shoofly pies, 2 pecan pies or 1 of each

Item Shape: