View Cart

Buy Amish-style shoofly pie online from our Lancaster County, PA bakery. Nationwide delivery.

Showing all 5 results

  • Shoofly Pie Plus Whoopie Sampler

    $31.25
    Select options
  • Shoofly Pie Gift Box

    From: $19.75
    Add to cart
  • Grandma Smucker’s Shoofly Pie

    $14.75
    Add to cart
  • Double Delight Pie Lover’s Gift Box

    $34.70
    Select options
  • Shoofly Pie Bonus Gift Bundle

    From: $44.25
    Add to cart